Apples and Oranges: In Praise of Comparisons by Maarten Asscher,Brian Doyle-Du Breuil

By Maarten Asscher,Brian Doyle-Du Breuil

What does it suggest while humans say “You can’t evaluate apples and oranges”? Are comparisons throughout genres inherently invalid, or can they be insightful and illuminating? during this very good and provocative number of essays, Dutch writer Maarten Asscher continues that comparisons could be the top type of argument.

Asscher makes his case with examples drawn from classical to modern historical past, artwork, and literature: Hamlet in Ithaca and Telemachus in Elsinore, the Mediterranean and the North Sea, writing from a jail mobilephone and writing from a room at domestic, the “suicide” of Primo Levi and jap Kamikaze pilots, etc. With swish erudition and idiosyncratic wit, Asscher demonstrates how the comparative strategy delivers perception not just into matters concurrently, but in addition into basic matters they could have in common.

Show description

Read or Download Apples and Oranges: In Praise of Comparisons PDF

Best epistemology books

Bertrand Russell on Nuclear War, Peace, and Language: Critical and Historical Essays (Contributions in Philosophy,)

Some of the most fashionable philosophers and activists of the twentieth century, Bertrand Russell is understood not just for his primary contributions at the scope of human wisdom and on mathematical common sense, but additionally for his often-controversial perspectives on moral and linguistic issues. This edited choice of unique essays by means of favorite Russell students makes a speciality of the philosopher's positions at the key problems with nuclear conflict, peace, and language.

Social Theory in a Changing World: Conceptions of Modernity

This e-book offers a serious evaluation of latest social conception for college students within the social sciences. Delanty examines the writings of a couple of key modern thinkers, together with Habermas, Foucault, Bauman, Touraine, Giddens and Beck, and offers a transparent account of the strengths and barriers in their paintings.


We all know approximately our rapid environment—about the folk, animals, and issues round us—by having sensory perceptions. based on a convention that strains again to Plato, we all know approximately summary reality—about arithmetic, morality, and metaphysics—by having intuitions, that are regarded as highbrow perceptions.

Pretense and Pathology: Philosophical Fictionalism and its Applications

During this ebook, Bradley Armour-Garb and James A. Woodbridge distinguish a variety of species of fictionalism, finding and protecting their very own model of philosophical fictionalism. Addressing semantic and philosophical puzzles that come up from usual language, they think about such concerns because the challenge of non-being, plural identification claims, mental-attitude ascriptions, that means attributions, and truth-talk.

Additional resources for Apples and Oranges: In Praise of Comparisons

Sample text

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.75 of 5 – based on 37 votes